If you’re planning a vacation to Hawaiʻi Island, one of the most common questions we hear at Kohala Coast Properties is:
“Do I really need a rental car on the Big Island?”
The short answer? Yes. You absolutely do.
The Big Island is magnificent, wild, and wonderfully spread out. And while that’s exactly what makes it so special, it’s also the reason you’ll need your own wheels to experience it properly.
Let’s break it down so you can plan ahead and make the most of your stay.
The Big Island Is Big — Really Big
The name says it all. Hawaiʻi Island is larger than all the other Hawaiian islands combined. You can drive for hours and still not see everything.
From the white sand beaches of the Kohala Coast to the lush waterfalls near Hilo…
From snorkeling at Kealakekua Bay to watching lava glow in Volcano…
From stargazing atop Mauna Kea to exploring black sand beaches…
These experiences are scattered across hundreds of miles.
There is no comprehensive public transportation system designed for sightseeing. Ride-sharing services are available in some areas, but they are limited and unreliable outside resort zones. Walking? Not realistic. Even within resort communities, distances between beaches, restaurants, and grocery stores can be significant.
If you want flexibility, freedom, and the ability to explore on your own schedule, a rental car is essential.
Why It’s Even More Important Right Now
There’s another factor visitors need to know about:
The Current Rental Car Shortage
Right now, Hawaiʻi Island is experiencing a noticeable rental car shortage.
One major reason? The renewed excitement around volcanic events at Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park.
Whenever there is visible lava or increased volcanic phenomena, visitors from around the world flock to the island to witness this rare natural spectacle. It’s an incredible experience — and understandably high on many travelers’ bucket lists.
But increased tourism means increased demand for rental vehicles.
And since the Big Island already has fewer rental car fleets than major mainland destinations, inventory can disappear quickly — primarily during peak vacation seasons.
We’ve seen many visitors arrive assuming they’ll secure a car upon landing, only to discover there are none available.
That’s not the way you want to start your vacation.
Book Your Rental Car as Soon as You Book Your Flight
Our best advice?
Reserve your rental car the moment you confirm your travel dates.
Ideally, book it at the same time you purchase your airline tickets. This ensures:
- You get better rates
- You secure availability
- You can pick up your car directly at the airport
- You avoid final-minute stress
Picking up your vehicle at the airport — whether at Kona International Airport (KOA) or Hilo International Airport (ITO) — is by far the most convenient option. You land, grab your luggage, and you’re on your way.
If you wait until a few weeks before your trip, especially during busy periods, you may find limited options or significantly higher prices.
Planning ahead saves money and gives peace of mind.
What If Traditional Rental Cars Are Sold Out?
If you’ve waited too long or you’re traveling during an especially busy period, don’t panic. There are alternative options — but each comes with considerations.
1. Turo
Turo has become a popular alternative to traditional rental companies.
Turo is essentially a peer-to-peer car-sharing platform where private vehicle owners rent their cars directly to guests.
It can be a great option — especially when rental agencies are fully booked.
However, there are important things to keep in mind:
- Check the host’s reviews and ratings carefully.
- Read all details about insurance coverage.
- Confirm mileage limits and fuel policies.
- Understand pickup and return procedures.
One major consideration: Not all Turo vehicles are available for airport pickup.
Some hosts require you to meet them off-site. That could mean arranging a taxi or Uber to a residential area to collect your vehicle, which may be inconvenient after a long flight.
Still, if traditional rental companies are sold out, Turo can be a practical backup plan — just be thorough and cautious when booking.
2. Craigslist
Craigslist is another possible resource.
Some local individuals and smaller businesses advertise rental vehicles under:
- Automotive Services
- Travel Services
If you go this route, exercise caution:
- Verify legitimacy
- Meet in safe, public locations
- Confirm registration and insurance
- Get all agreements in writing
This option is less common for visitors, but during peak shortages, it can be worth exploring.
Why Having a Car Makes Your Trip Better
Beyond necessity, having your own car truly improves your Big Island experience.
Here’s why:
1. Freedom to Explore
Want to chase a sunset along the Kohala Coast?
Decide last minute to snorkel at a secluded beach?
Hear that lava viewing conditions are perfect tonight?
With your own vehicle, you can go.
Without one, you’re confined to walking distance or limited resort shuttles.
2. Access to Groceries & Local Dining
Many visitors stay in vacation rental condos or homes — and for good reason.
At Kohala Coast Properties, we specialize in beautiful private vacation rentals along the Kohala Coast. Guests love having:
- Full kitchens
- Spacious lanais
- Large living areas
- Privacy and comfort
Yet to truly enjoy that convenience, you’ll want to shop at local grocery stores, farmers markets, and specialty shops — which require driving.
You’ll also want the flexibility to check out local dining spots beyond resort restaurants.
3. Scenic Drives Are Part of the Experience
On the Big Island, the trip itself is often just as memorable as the destination.
The drive from the sunny Kohala Coast to the lush east side of the island feels like traveling between worlds. Within an hour or two, landscapes shift dramatically:
- Lava fields
- Rainforests
- Rolling paniolo (cowboy) country
- Dramatic coastal cliffs
The transitions are part of what makes Hawaiʻi Island so extraordinary.
And they’re best experienced at your own pace.
What Type of Vehicle Should You Rent?
Most visitors do perfectly fine with a standard sedan or SUV.
However, consider:
- If you plan to explore rugged or unpaved roads, a higher-clearance vehicle may be helpful.
- Check rental agreements carefully before driving on unpaved roads — many contracts prohibit it.
- Four-wheel drive is not required for the most popular destinations.
For beach days, SUVs offer extra room for chairs, coolers, and snorkel gear.
A Word About Cost
Yes, rental cars on the Big Island can be expensive — especially during shortages.
But think of it this way:
The cost of not having a car can be far greater in lost experiences, inconvenience, and limited mobility.
Hawaiʻi Island isn’t a compact, walkable destination. It’s a place of great distances, dramatic landscapes, and secret treasures.
Your rental car isn’t just transportation — it’s your key to the island.
Final Advice from Kohala Coast Properties
At Kohala Coast Properties, we want your vacation to be flawless and unforgettable.
Here’s our simple recommendation:
✔ Book your rental car as soon as you book your trip.
✔ Pick up at the airport whenever possible.
✔ Have a backup plan (like Turo) if traditional rentals are unavailable.
✔ Read the fine print on alternative rentals.
The Big Island rewards those who plan ahead.
With your own vehicle, you can:
- Explore hidden beaches
- Visit Hawaiʻi Volcanoes National Park
- Discover charming towns
- Experience dramatic climate zones
- Create spontaneous island memories
Without one? You’ll miss out on much of what makes this island magical.
The Big Island isn’t meant to be seen from a hotel balcony alone.
It’s meant to be explored.
And for that, you absolutely need a car.